Analyst Advocates for Increased Investment in Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) Despite Market Fluctuations

Nov 2, 2025 at 5:13 PM

Despite recent market volatility and a downgrade from Wells Fargo, a prominent equity strategist remains optimistic about Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) and is increasing his stake in the company. His confidence stems from factors beyond the speculative interest in rare earths, focusing instead on the company's core business and evolving market dynamics. This strategic outlook highlights the importance of discerning long-term value from short-term market reactions.

Strategic Investment in Cleveland-Cliffs: Beyond Rare Earths

A leading equity strategist at Cerity Partners, Jim Lebenthal, is showing increased confidence in Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) by boosting his investment, even though the stock has recently experienced a dip. His decision comes after the company's shares initially climbed following positive quarterly results, only to fall significantly due to a Wells Fargo downgrade that dismissed enthusiasm surrounding rare earths as excessive. Lebenthal, however, emphasizes that his bullish stance on Cleveland-Cliffs is not influenced by rare earth prospects but by more fundamental aspects of the business.

Lebenthal's rationale for investing further in Cleveland-Cliffs is grounded in a shifting market narrative. He points to an anticipated surge in demand within the automotive sector, a crucial segment for Cleveland-Cliffs, which accounts for a substantial portion of its operations. The company has secured favorable contracts with major original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) for the next two to three years, ensuring stable revenue streams. Furthermore, a new memorandum of understanding with an international steel firm is set to leverage Cleveland-Cliffs' underutilized assets and facilities, promising new growth avenues. These developments collectively indicate a positive trajectory for the company, suggesting that its intrinsic value is on the rise independent of any rare earth-related speculation.

Automotive Sector Revival and Strategic Alliances Fuel CLF's Potential

The strategist's optimism for Cleveland-Cliffs is largely driven by a robust recovery in the automotive industry and key strategic partnerships. The narrative around the company is undergoing a significant transformation, with auto demand showing clear signs of an uptick. This resurgence is particularly beneficial for Cleveland-Cliffs, given that the automotive sector constitutes a major part of its business. The firm has successfully negotiated and signed contracts with prominent automotive manufacturers, locking in favorable pricing for its products over the coming years, which is expected to stabilize and boost its financial performance.

Beyond the automotive recovery, a pivotal element supporting Lebenthal's investment thesis is Cleveland-Cliffs' proactive engagement in new strategic alliances. A recently inked memorandum of understanding with a global steel company signifies an innovative approach to growth, where dormant assets and facilities can be reactivated to generate new revenue streams. This move is indicative of Cleveland-Cliffs' adaptability and strategic foresight in capitalizing on market opportunities. The combination of sustained automotive demand and strategic operational leverage positions Cleveland-Cliffs for considerable growth, making it an attractive investment target despite any short-term market fluctuations or analyst downgrades that may overlook these fundamental strengths.