Shkreli's Opendoor Short Faces Criticism Amid Rate-Cut Rally

Sep 18, 2025 at 5:01 AM
Single Slide

Investor Martin Shkreli, widely recognized as \"Pharma Bro,\" has recently faced scrutiny regarding his short position on Opendoor Technologies Inc. (OPEN). The real estate platform's stock experienced a significant surge following the Federal Reserve's decision to cut interest rates. Shkreli, a vocal critic of Opendoor, dismissed the backlash, asserting the unsuitability of mocking his investment choices when they don't align with his expectations. He maintains that Opendoor is fundamentally flawed, an \"obvious short,\" and has committed to an extensive due diligence campaign to support his claims, even as the stock exhibits strong upward momentum and a substantial short interest.

The controversy began after Shkreli publicly disclosed his shorting of Opendoor shares at $9.36. His position immediately came under pressure as Opendoor's stock price climbed significantly, particularly on Wednesday when it rose by 14.46%, contributing to a 34.61% increase for the week. This rally coincided with the Federal Reserve's announcement of a 25 basis point rate cut, bringing the target range to 4.00%-4.25%, marking the end of a nine-month hiatus in the easing cycle.

Shkreli, undeterred by the stock's performance, took to social media to express his disapproval of those who derided his investment strategy. He reiterated his long-held belief that Opendoor's business model is inherently unsound. In previous statements, he had labeled the company an \"obvious short,\" advising against long positions, and even suggesting that individuals invested in it should reconsider their investment capabilities.

To bolster his short thesis, Shkreli unveiled plans for a comprehensive due diligence initiative. This campaign involves engaging with a diverse group of stakeholders, including former employees, current customers, industry competitors, and potentially even Opendoor's management. He committed to sharing insights from these discussions, either through direct invites to calls or by releasing anonymous transcripts, emphasizing transparency in his efforts.

Last week, Shkreli acknowledged the appointment of Kaz Nejatian as Opendoor's new CEO, surprisingly calling it a \"big win.\" However, this recognition did not alter his fundamental assessment of the company. He continued to assert that Opendoor was \"fundamentally broken\" and expressed skepticism about its potential for recovery, suggesting that the core issues hindering its viability remained unresolved despite leadership changes.

Despite Shkreli's bearish stance, market data indicates a complex picture for Opendoor. According to Benzinga Pro, the company's short interest stands at a considerable 26.6% of its total outstanding shares. This figure is notably higher than the median S&P 500 stock's float of 2.3%, suggesting a significant portion of investors are betting against the stock. Conversely, technical indicators paint a more optimistic outlook. The stock's Relative Strength Index (RSI) is currently at 59.124, signaling a \"Buy\" recommendation and suggesting moderate upward momentum. This divergence between fundamental criticism and technical indicators highlights the speculative nature surrounding Opendoor's future performance.

In the aftermath of the rate cut and the ensuing market rally, Opendoor shares closed at $10.21 on Wednesday, with an additional 1.18% gain in after-hours trading. The stock has also achieved high ratings in Benzinga's Edge Stock Rankings for Momentum, indicating favorable price trends across short, medium, and long-term horizons. This situation underscores the volatile and unpredictable dynamics of the market, where a prominent investor's short position can be challenged by broader economic shifts and evolving market sentiment.