Oscar Health Stock: Undervalued and Poised for Growth

Sep 17, 2025 at 2:30 PM

Oscar Health's stock has demonstrated robust performance, climbing 21% since an earlier strong buy recommendation, significantly outpacing the S&P 500's modest 4% gain. This impressive growth is underpinned by substantial increases in its member base and expanding market presence. Despite a temporary uptick in its medical loss ratio, the company's financial results show a strong upward trend in revenue. Positioned at a considerably lower valuation multiple compared to its competitors, Oscar Health continues to offer an attractive investment prospect with promising fundamentals and future growth potential.

Oscar Health, traded under the ticker OSCR on the NYSE, has proven to be a dynamic player in the healthcare sector. The company's stock experienced a 21% surge, far exceeding the S&P 500's 4% return over the same period. This indicates a strong market response to Oscar Health's operational and strategic advancements. A key driver of this success is its rapidly expanding membership base, which surpassed 2.0 million by June 2025. This represents a remarkable 28% year-over-year increase, significantly outperforming the broader Affordable Care Act (ACA) market growth of just 13%.

The company's strategic focus on expansion is evident in its growing geographical footprint. Oscar Health now offers coverage in 18 states and across 446 counties, with ambitious plans to enter an additional 150 new metropolitan areas by 2027. This aggressive expansion strategy is a primary catalyst for its continued growth and market penetration. Financial performance in the second quarter of 2025 further highlights Oscar Health's upward trajectory, with revenue soaring by 29% year-over-year to $2.86 billion. While the medical loss ratio (MLR) temporarily climbed to 91.1% from 79.0%, this is viewed as a short-term fluctuation within a broader context of strong revenue generation.

From an investment perspective, Oscar Health remains notably undervalued. The company is currently trading at approximately 0.45 times its revenues, a stark contrast to its peers, who average a multiple of 3.19 times. This significant discrepancy suggests that the market may not yet fully recognize Oscar Health's inherent value and growth prospects. The combination of strong membership growth, strategic market expansion, impressive revenue increases, and a low valuation multiple points to considerable upside potential for investors.

In summary, Oscar Health's recent stock performance and operational achievements underscore its potential as a compelling investment. The company has demonstrated robust growth in membership and revenue, driven by a clear and aggressive expansion strategy. Despite some temporary financial fluctuations, its underlying fundamentals remain strong, and its current market valuation suggests it is significantly undervalued compared to industry peers. For investors seeking opportunities in the dynamic healthcare market, Oscar Health represents a promising prospect with substantial room for future appreciation.